IPC OUTLOOK Logo
The Knowledge and Know-how Connection
IPC OUTLOOK Logo
June 19, 2013
Ten Rules for Jumper Wires
Ten Rules for Jumper Wires
Production Floor
Overcoming Repair Depot Challenges
Overcoming Repair Depot Challenges
Production Floor
Jumper Wire Nightmare!
Jumper Wire Nightmare!
Production Floor
Best Method for Repairing Underfill Arrays?
Best Method for Repairing Underfill Arrays?
Board Talk
Is There a Thermal Cycle Limit?
Is There a Thermal Cycle Limit?
Board Talk
Rework or Repair?
Rework or Repair?
Ask the Experts
What is the Reliability of Reballed BGAs?
What is the Reliability of Reballed BGAs?
Production Floor
Test Method to Characterize Pad Cratering
Test Method to Characterize Pad Cratering
Analysis Lab
BGA Site Modification - Is It Possible?
BGA Site Modification - Is It Possible?
Production Floor
BGA Rework Flux Recommendation
BGA Rework Flux Recommendation
Ask the Experts
More Related Programs  »
Featured Sponsor - please stay tuned ...   »
A Century of Global Soldering Leadership
A Century of Global Soldering Leadership
Why spend so much time developing profiles for every board, when Vitronics Soltec's Autoset can do it for you, automatically?
Vitronics Soltec

Is Alloy Mixing During Rework Acceptable?
Is Alloy Mixing During Rework Acceptable?
A board may bear a RoHS label, but the lead-free solder alloy is not known. What is the best rework procedure to follow?
ITM Consulting
Board Talk is presented by ITM Consulting

Visit ITM Consulting to learn more.

Phil Zarrow
Phil Zarrow, ITM Consulting
With over 35 years experience in PCB assembly, Phil is one of the leading experts in SMT process failure analysis. He has vast experience in SMT equipment, materials and processes.

Jim Hall
Jim Hall, ITM Consulting
A Lean Six-Sigma Master Blackbelt, Jim has a wealth of knowledge in soldering, thermal technology, equipment and process basics. He is a pioneer in the science of reflow.
Comments  » Submit a Comment  »


There is another situation: The product is lead-free soldered due to availability of BGA with lead-free balls. Now, we have few parts to rework, the product does not need RoHS label but was soldered with SAC305.

Now, we need to touch up the joint using regular 63/37 Tin-Lead solder alloy. The reworked parts are discrete and ICs. (if BGA reworked, it is with SAC305 only)

Do you see any problem with mixing of alloys when RoHS label is not required by the customer?


Ashok Dhawan, P. Eng., Manufacturing Specialist, Parker Hannifin Canada



Let's start with the premise that the assembly must meet the print requirements. The solder alloy to be used is listed on the drawing, including any exceptions (for example, Note 1. "Use Sn63Pb37 solder, except BGA U1 which may have SAC305 solder balls").

In order to rework the assembly back into compliance with the print requirement, you should always be able to get a copy of the original assembly print from the customer to determine the solder alloy requirements and exceptions, and rework accordingly. If the assembly print no longer exists, then an appropriate waiver from the customer is needed before mixing alloys or removing old solder and reworking with different alloys.

You can't just fly by the seat of your pants with issues such as solder alloys. These are critical items and must be kept controlled. It doesn't really matter if it is a stereo component or a flight control. If you rework solder on 1,000 stereo amplifiers with the wrong alloy and reliability issues result, you will be getting The Call from your friends at Davidowitz, Davidowitz, and Davidowitz, Attorneys at Law!


Richard Stadem

Sponsors   »
IPC OUTLOOK Logo IPC — Association Connecting Electronics Industries
3000 Lakeside Drive, 309 S, Bannockburn, IL 60015
Phone: 978-478-5112 | Fax: 843-682-4255
Sandy Gentry, Editor | Neal Bender, Membership Director
About IPC Outlook  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use  |  Sponsorships
Programs: 900+  |  Directory Listings: 1450+  |  IPC Members: 3100+
Subscribers: 100,000+


Views: 3129