IPC OUTLOOK Logo
The Knowledge and Know-how Connection
IPC OUTLOOK Logo
May 21, 2012
VOC Free Flux Study
Analysis Lab
Enhancing Reliability of PB-Free Solder Joints
Materials Tech
Second Generation Pb-Free Alloys
Materials Tech
Reusing Solder Paste Samples
Ask the Experts
Processing and Reliability of Low Silver Alloys
Materials Tech
Developing a New Lead-Free Alloy
Materials Tech
NASA DoD Environments Testing Results
Analysis Lab
Will High Humidity Affect Reflow Soldering
Board Talk
The Proliferation of Lead-free Alloys
Materials Tech
How To Control Flux When Hand Soldering?
Board Talk
More Related Programs  »



HASL vs. Immersion Gold
We make electronic equipment used in corrosive environments. Do you recommend use ...
Cleaning with Sodium Bicarbonate
Is there an affect on PCBA long term reliability for assemblies cleaned ...
BGA Component Moisture Exposure
We mistakenly assembled boards using BGA components with moisture tags that show ...
Mixed Technology - Which First
We are assembling a mixed technology board. We assemble the through hole ...
Insufficient Plated Hole Fill with Electrolytic Capacitors
We are having problems achieving the minimum hole of 75% on electrolytic ...
BGA Rework Flux Recommendation
Is there a flux we should evaluate when we replace BGA components? ...
What is Causing Oxidation?
After 2-3 months of service in the field we are noticing the ...
Rework or Repair?
We often need to strip solder splash contamination off gold edge contacts ...
Proper DI Water Resistivity for PCB Cleaning?
What the proper resistivity reading for DI water when cleaning electronic assemblies ...
Cold Solder Joints on 0603 Components
We encountered cold solder joints on 0603 components on a batch of ...
More Ask the Experts  »
Does Lead-free Flux Make a Difference?
Does Lead-free Flux Make a Difference?
Does using a lead-free solder flux really make a difference? Why not use the same flux we use for leaded soldering?

Does using a lead free solder flux really make a difference? Why not use the same flux we use for leaded soldering in our lead free process?


T. F.


Expert's Panel Responses

Fluxes do not contain metals, such as lead, so all fluxes are lead free. Your question must be asking about flux that is marketed as being specially formulated for use with lead free alloy. The answer is: you will not know unless you try it. Notall lead free alloys work equally well with all fluxes. Flux can be formulated to achieve superior results with aspecific lead free alloy.

When claims such as this are made, I recommend contacting the manufacturer and asking for a FREE sample so you can prove to yourself that their claim is valid. Be sure to evaluate the qualities of the residue when you do your testing. Some "lead free" fluxes just have higher activity levels to compensate for the moredifficult wetting andhigher reflow temperature.

In some cases with no-clean fluxes, a certain minimum reflow time is required to consume their activator so the residue is in fact no-clean.



image
John Vivari
Application Engineering Supervisor, Nordson EFD
Mr. Vivari has more than ten years of electronic engineering design and assembly experience. His expertise in fluid dispensing and solder paste technology assists others in identifying the most cost effective method for assembling products.

Lead-free alloys wet slower, have a greater surface tension, and operate at higher temperatures compared to tin/lead.

There are older chemistries which work with lead-free alloys, but they are typically not an optimal choice.

A flux which has been specifically developed for lead-free applications, is by design capable of accommodating the demands these alloys make on the soldering process, thus providing a more optimal process window for the end user.



image
Mike Scimeca
President, FCT Assembly
Mike Scimeca created FCT Assembly after the purchase of Fine Line Stencil, Inc., and consists of two major operations: stencil manufacturing and the manufacturing of electronic assembly products such as solder paste, flux and solder bar.

From the wording of your question, it isn't clear if you are referring to a lead-free flux for a surface mount application (solder paste flux), a wave soldering application (liquid flux) or a hand soldering application (cored wire flux), but in each case, at least to some degree, there is certainly value in utilizing fluxes are known to be lead-free capable.

Although some fluxes that had originally had been designed for leaded applications may work acceptablyinlead-free applications, there are many new fluxes on the market today that were designed specifically for lead-free soldering processes. These fluxes represent improvements over traditional fluxes in terms of solderability.

Since lead-free alloys melt at higher temperatures and don't spread as easily as leaded alloys, lead-free compatible fluxes tend to have higher activity and higher heat stability than traditional fluxes. This gives most users reason enough to make the switch to a newer flux that was designed specifically for lead-free processes.



image
Brian Smith
General Manager - Electronic Assembly Americas, DEK International
Mr. Smith has been supporting customers in the electronics assembly industry since 1994. His expertise is focused on solder paste printing and reducing soldering defects. He holds a BS in Chemical Engineering and an MBA in Marketing. He has authored several papers in trade magazines and at industry conferences. He is an SMTA Certified Process Engineer.

Yes, due to the higher reflow temperatures and longer soak times if you tried to use eutectic flux in a lead free application the fluxes would activate too soon in the cycle and not be available during the reflow of the solder joint.



image
Edward Zamborsky
Regional Sales Manager, OK International Inc.
Mr. Zamborsky serves as one of OK's technology advisers to the Product Development group. Ed has authored articles and papers on topics such as; Low Volume SMT Assembly, Solder Fume Extraction, SMT Rework, BGA Rework, Lead Free Hand Soldering, Lead Free Visual Inspection and Lead Free Array Rework.
Print  »
At "Ask the Experts" we submit challenging questions to our panel of distinguished experts. You provide the questions and they provide the answers.

Ask the Experts Questions | Ask the Experts Panel
Submit A Questions | Join the Panel
Comments  »
Use the form below to submit a comment.
My question is, what is the difference of using lead-free solder (wire core, flux) vs lead, it could affect field operation failures? Most of our electronics assemblies are general assemblies (not PCB's) and I know that it depends of our customer requirements, but sometimes customer do not specify or simple don't care as long as assembly works. Most of the plants use lead solder as a default, wondering why?

Carlos Moreno, Avnet
Submit A Comment  »
This comment is about the program:
Does Lead-free Flux Make a Difference?

The is a general comment.
Your Name
Company
E-mail
Country
Comments
Discussion of pricing, recommendations for specific products or advertisements are not appropriate. All comments are reviewed prior to posting. You must include your full name to have your comments posted. We will not post your email address, we request your email address so we can notify you if your comments are posted.
Authentication
Please type the number displayed into the box. If you attempt to submit information and receive an error, you may need to refresh the page and insert the information again.
Today's Sponsor
Today's Sponsor
IPC Member Spotlight   »
Featured Sponsors   »
IPC OUTLOOK Logo IPC — Association Connecting Electronics Industries
3000 Lakeside Drive, 309 S, Bannockburn, IL 60015
Phone: 978-478-5112 | Fax: 843-682-4255
Sandy Gentry, Editor | Kim Sterling, Publisher
About IPC Outlook  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use  |  Sponsorships

Views: 508