IPC OUTLOOK Logo
The Knowledge and Know-how Connection
IPC OUTLOOK Logo
June 18, 2013
What Causes Black Pad?
What Causes Black Pad?
Ask the Experts
Gold Contact Flux Contamination Failures
Gold Contact Flux Contamination Failures
Ask the Experts
Pad Cratering Evaluation of PCBs
Pad Cratering Evaluation of PCBs
Materials Tech
The Effects of Flux Residues on Reliability
The Effects of Flux Residues on Reliability
Analysis Lab
What is Causing Oxidation?
What is Causing Oxidation?
Ask the Experts
Corrosive Driven Whisker Growth in SAC305
Corrosive Driven Whisker Growth in SAC305
Analysis Lab
Sticky Residue Under Low Clearance Parts
Sticky Residue Under Low Clearance Parts
Board Talk
Issues with Circuit Boards Exposed to Rain
Issues with Circuit Boards Exposed to Rain
Ask the Experts
Lead-Free Solder Contaminated with Lead
Lead-Free Solder Contaminated with Lead
Ask the Experts
Are Gloves Required for PCB Handling?
Are Gloves Required for PCB Handling?
Board Talk
More Related Programs  »
What is an Acceptable Level of Exposed Copper?
What is an Acceptable Level of Exposed Copper?
Is there an acceptable level of exposed copper on gold plated circuit boards where all the conductors are gold plated?
Print  »

Jim 
Phil, this is an anonymous question. We don't even have the initials of the perpetrator of this question It relates to the surface finishes on finished circuit boards.

The question is: "Is there a general specification for an acceptable level of exposed copper for circuit conductors on circuit boards where all the copper surfaces are gold plated?" And a further question is: "What problems could we see if there are very small non-contact areas if some conductors have exposed copper?"

Phil
Well let's see, the answer to the first question, general specification: YES - generally speaking there shouldn't be any exposed copper. As far as potential problems you could see, well obviously that copper can corrode, discolor.

The thing here is, we would politely say, "This a process indicator." It's also a supplier indicator. What kind of crappy boards are you buying? What's with this exposed copper? Hey, it's supposed to be gold plated, why the hell is the copper showing through here? You know what's going on here? This is a process out of control.

Jim
But let's apply some logic to this, Brother Phil. What is special about gold?

Phil
It's expensive..

Jim
Right, so in the fab process that calls for gold coating, obviously any supplier doesn't want to put anymore gold on than they absolutely have to.

Now what happens in real life? Some board fabricators are reasonable about that, they try to keep it low, but well within the specs. Others try to take it right to the limit of the spec.

Phil
And cross over the line.

Jim
So one thing might be here as a process indicator, you might want to measure the average thickness of the gold on the other conductors. Is it not only exposed on little edges and so forth, but is it really thin on the other places so you can't see it, but whereas it might not give you 100% protection? The question I would have is: Are you getting good soldering on all of your joints that are supposedly fully protected by this gold coating?

Phil
And I'd particularly concerned also about the inside barrels of the through-holes and vias. If you're seeing it on the surface, one can only wonder what's beneath. If it's exposed copper, wow, the guys even skipping on the nickel for crying out loud. What is this world coming to, Jim?

Jim
Well remember, we don't know that. There are flash gold finishes that go right over copper, Phil, so we don't know that specifically here. We typically think of a ENIG finish where we get a nickel barrier, and I agree with Phil, but we don't have data here to make that claim.

If it is a ENIG finish and you got exposed copper, then Phil's right; not only did they not get the gold on, but they didn't get the nickel on, which brings us to another thing that you have to ask is: Was it not a problem with the gold being too thin but the fact that the copper wasn't cleaned adequately underneath, and that's death with any finish. Just remember, I don't care what your surface finish is - OSP, immersion silver, HASL or anything, you're starting with bare copper and you've got to get that copper clean.

All of the surface coating methodologies start by actually etching a little bit of the copper off to get any deep seated corrosion. You get down to really virgin copper. So whatever finish you put on gold or nickel or whatever, you can get a good complete coverage.

Phil
So coming or going, it's a process out of control. This case it could be poor cleaning at one end and/or skimping on the gold at the back end. Nevertheless, it might be time to look for another vendor or get this one in line.

Jim
Yes, unfortunately where so much of the PCB fab is gone offshore, the supply link is longer and problems have increased.

ITM Consulting
Board Talk is presented by ITM Consulting

Visit ITM Consulting to learn more.

Phil Zarrow
Phil Zarrow, ITM Consulting
With over 35 years experience in PCB assembly, Phil is one of the leading experts in SMT process failure analysis. He has vast experience in SMT equipment, materials and processes.

Jim Hall
Jim Hall, ITM Consulting
A Lean Six-Sigma Master Blackbelt, Jim has a wealth of knowledge in soldering, thermal technology, equipment and process basics. He is a pioneer in the science of reflow.
Comments  » Submit a Comment  »


There were some talks few years back about gold directly over bare copper surface finish. Where soldering will be done directly to copper and the gold is acting as a corrosion resistance. I believe Macdermid was involved with such process. What happened to this finish? Is anyone in the industry using it?

Sherif Refaat, TRCI, Canada



SnCu is being proposed as an alternate to SAC materials because they are cheaper and supposedly process better. Why shouldn't I convert all my SAC PCBA to SnCu if it's so good. There have to be negatives.

Timothy Holder, GE Consumer & Industrial



Did I miss the answer to the question? Is there an acceptable level of exposed copper on flex and rigid boards?

Michael Schulz

Sponsors   »
IPC OUTLOOK Logo IPC — Association Connecting Electronics Industries
3000 Lakeside Drive, 309 S, Bannockburn, IL 60015
Phone: 978-478-5112 | Fax: 843-682-4255
Sandy Gentry, Editor | Neal Bender, Membership Director
About IPC Outlook  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use  |  Sponsorships
Programs: 900+  |  Directory Listings: 1450+  |  IPC Members: 3100+
Subscribers: 100,000+


Views: 1212